I have written about things that husbands should say to their wives, and now it’s time to write about the things that we should not say. I will admit right now that I have said them, but I learned after a few times that it is not a very good idea to do so. These phrases are among the worst relationship killers. They are very useful for either starting or perpetuating a conflict. Avoid them like tainted peanut butter. I do.
1. You always do that.
It took me awhile to figure out that this phrase is not helpful. I had to first pay attention to how it made me feel when other people said it to me. It’s horrible because (1) it is usually an exaggeration, (2) it is accusatory rather than restorative, and (3) it is one-sided.
Before you start to tell your wife that she “always” does something, stop and think. What would she say if you asked her to list the things that you “always” do that hurt or bother her? What would your friends say if you posed that question to them? Let’s face it: we all have bad habits and character flaws that can bug or offend other people. You are no exception.
An alternative to saying, “You always do that,” is “It bothers (or hurts) me when you do that.” First, you are taking at least part of the responsibility on yourself when you say it that way. Second, you are referring to specific instances rather than to “always.” If delivered well and at the right time, your wife is likely to work on the behavior in question. Make sure that you reciprocate, though. She’s not likely to change any of her behavior if you are unwilling to change yours.
2. What’s the matter with you?
Unless you are expressing sincere concern, this is a very bad thing to ask.
I have made the error of saying it when my wife has (1) made a silly mistake, (2) expressed a contrary opinion, or (3) been out of sorts for some reason, including during her monthly cycle. In all three instances, it is very unhelpful. Everyone makes mistakes, including you. Learn to live with them. Your wife is entitled to a different opinion, and she might just be right sometimes. If you cannot put up with a little irritability, you weren’t ready to get married, but you did, so grow up. And if you don’t know about estrogen and progesterone, learn.
I still forget about hormones. My wife and I sometimes have little quarrels about silly things, and I’m too oblivious to remember that it has been one month since the last such quarrel. I sometimes think, “What’s the matter with her,” but I have learned not to say it. I have learned to take those things in stride and love her through them.
3. If you loved me, you would do it.
If you love her, you will not say this. Early on I used it to try to get my wife to agree to several different things. One that I remember is that I wanted her to stop asking me questions when she wanted me to do something, as in, “Do you think that somebody should replace the lightbulb on the porch?” I like directness and would prefer that she just say, “Please replace the lightbulb on the porch.” She was too timid to be that direct. I told her that if she loved me, she would approach me in the way that I was most comfortable. She wasn’t amused.
Love does not entitle you to coerce your wife into doing things that she doesn’t want to do, and emotional blackmail is about the worst kind of coercion that there is. You’re a man: use your masculine negotiation skills. First, express what you want and why it is important to you. Second, offer something in return, and make it bigger and better than what you are asking for. Third, be willing to settle for something less. If all that fails, be patient. Maybe your wife will give in at some future time, especially if you are really nice to her in the meantime.
4. You’re just like. . . .
Fill in the blank. Perhaps you want to compare her to her mother or to your mother or maybe to someone else. It’s a huge mistake. It’s not accurate, because nobody is just like anybody else, and it certainly isn’t nice.
If you haven’t noticed how complex a woman’s relationship with her mother is, learn. If you haven’t noticed how complex a woman’s relationship is with her mother-in-law is, learn.
Whoever your wife is like, she’s a unique person. Treat her as such. You married her, so you got what you asked for. Now love her for who she is and for whom she will become as you both mature.
5. All you have to do is. . .
It took me several years to really understand that my wife does not want me to instruct her. I am a very helpful person by nature, and as a man I approach life as a series of complications to be solved. When my wife discusses a problem with me, I logically assess the situation and propose solutions. Guess what? That’s probably not what she wants.
Several female friends and some good marriage counselors told me, “She just wants you to listen.” I know it doesn’t make sense. It doesn’t make sense to me still. That’s one of the beautiful things about women in general: not everything makes “sense” to them in the way that things make “sense” to us. Please learn that fact and relish it. If your wife tended to attack problems as coldly and logically as you tend to do as a man, she would not be just what you need. She would not be your perfect complement.
If your wife is typical, she processes things more on an emotional level than you do. She processes things by talking about them. The mere act of telling you about something and seeing that you care may be the “solution” for her. As she talks, she might arrive at the same solution that you were goin to propose, but she wants to get there herself and in her own way. She just wants a sounding board. She just wants to know that somebody cares.